The competition, in their own words.
Four companies come up when a Toast restaurant looks for delivery software. For each one, this page lists what the company says about itself, then gives our read on where that falls short for the restaurant we are built for: high volume, its own drivers, and runs that have to be built fast.
Read from each company's own pages on Nov 16, 2026Marketing claims, not tested by usWhat BottomLine does, in the terms we are judging them by
A restaurant that delivers with its own drivers and does a lot of it. Orders are clustered on a map and grouped into runs, and a driver takes a run at the counter without typing.
- A separate screen pulls Toast delivery orders and plots and clusters them on a map, near-instantly.
- An order joins a run once it is marked ready. The rule for when that happens is still being decided.
- The driver picks a premade run, scans a QR code (one for Apple Maps, one for Google Maps) and the full route opens. Stops are in order and end back at the restaurant.
- When the delivery is signed out to the driver on the Toast screen, it leaves the BottomLine screen.
- Each store sets its own rules: deliveries per run, maximum distance between stops, delivery radius.
Where we stand today: Toast access is read-only. Each restaurant connects with its own Toast credentials. Write access would remove one more step, and we are asking for it. Clover is in testing.
Who they say they are for
| Company | Says it is | Own drivers | Batching and routes | Toast | Published price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shipday | AI delivery management software for restaurants, pizzerias, couriers, retail and more | Yes, plus hybrid dispatch to outside fleets | Multi-stop route planner, unlimited stops per route. A "smart batching" dispatch option appears in a product mockup | Listed in the Toast marketplace. Setup uses a Shipday API key | Free to $399 a month on the pricing page, with per-order charges past an included amount. Enterprise starts at $3,499 |
| VROMO | Delivery management software for restaurants and dark kitchens | Yes, plus overflow to outside fleets | Order stacking, auto-dispatch rules, route optimization. No batch size stated | Integration page. Orders pass from Toast to VROMO | $99 a month per location including 400 orders, then $0.25 per order |
| Cartwheel | Enterprise delivery management software for restaurant chains and catering brands | Yes, plus hybrid rules that send the rest to outside providers | AI auto-dispatch and auto-batching. One rule caps orders per driver | Toast marketplace. Toast's article says it needs Toast Partner Integrations | Starts at $65 a month per location in the US |
| DeliverThat | Catering delivery platform with its own nationwide driver network | Own drivers can appear in its dashboard. The product centres on its fleet | No batching or multi-stop claim on the pages read | Sends Toast catering orders to its drivers | None published. Says it charges a flat fee per delivery |
The most direct competitor. Shipday markets to pizzerias by name and calls running in-house drivers one of its most common setups.
What Shipday says
- It is software for businesses that use their own drivers or outside fleets, not a delivery service. It reports 7,500+ businesses and 30 million+ orders delivered.
- Routes: plan multi-stop routes in seconds and deliver up to 30% faster. It allows unlimited stops per route with no per-stop fee, and accounts for time windows, driver shifts, vehicle capacity and traffic. It re-optimizes when a stop is added or canceled.
- Dispatch: auto-assign to the closest available driver, with custom rules. A hybrid option sends orders to your own drivers first and to DoorDash, Uber, Roadie or Stuart as backup.
- Driver app: free on iOS and Android, with chat, GPS tracking, photo and signature proof of delivery and optimized routes. Driver payment calculation is on paid plans.
- Customers: live tracking, ETA, SMS and WhatsApp updates, a branded tracking page on paid plans.
- Toast: it says the integration is native in the Toast marketplace and free to enable. Setup is to copy the Shipday API key and paste it into the Location ID field in Toast. It says delivery orders flow in with address, items and contact filled in. It claims up to 80% fewer late deliveries and up to 90% fewer "where is my order" calls.
- Clover: connects through an authorization prompt in Clover. Read and write scope is not stated.
- Pizza proof it cites: Pizza My Heart (said to cut dispatch calls from 20 minutes to 90 seconds), Pizza Guys, Romeo's Pizza and others.
- Price: a free Basic plan capped at 300 orders a month without route planning or auto-dispatch. Professional Lite $29, Professional $49, Branded Elite $99, Business AI Lite $199, Business AI $399, with per-order charges past the included orders.
Where it falls short for us
- It is a general route optimizer. The route page is written for couriers, ecommerce, florists and grocery as well as restaurants: capacity, weight, time windows, depots. A pizzeria's problem is different. The food is ready at a certain moment and a driver is standing at the counter. Nothing we read describes how orders are held and released as the kitchen finishes them.
- No batching rules are given. Unlimited stops per route is not the same as a rule that says three orders, within one mile of each other, in the same direction. The only batching wording we found is a menu item in a product mockup, and no page says how it decides.
- Built around a dispatcher and a driver app. The route is created in the dashboard and sent to the driver's app. We found no description of a driver choosing a premade run at the counter and scanning it into Apple or Google Maps.
- The Toast handoff is unspecified. The page does not say whether Shipday reads only or also writes back, and it does not say what happens in Toast when a driver takes an order. A restaurant may end up signing orders out twice.
- Price grows with volume. Every paid plan has an included-order count and a per-order charge. The pricing page also contradicts itself on whether Professional and Business AI are unlimited, so the real number needs to be confirmed.
Where they are ahead of us
A Toast marketplace listing, proof of delivery, customer tracking links, driver pay calculation, a free tier, published pricing and thousands of customers. We should expect to be asked about each.
Pages read: home, pricing, pizzerias, route planning, Toast, Clover, driver app.
Restaurant delivery software that leans on stacking orders and handing the overflow to outside fleets.
What VROMO says
- Its headline is "Making restaurant delivery profitable." It says it was built specifically for restaurants and dark kitchens, and reports 9,000+ restaurant sites in 250+ cities.
- Stacking: pay one fee for several deliveries by merging orders. Route optimization is listed as a cost saver, with no method described.
- Auto-dispatch: custom rules per order, including driver distance to the store, restricted items, maximum jobs per driver and order value. It says timers can set when a job goes to drivers and that it can link to a kitchen display system.
- Overflow: sends extra orders to outside fleets such as DoorDash Drive, at discounted rates.
- Driver app on Android and iOS, with job offers, chat and push messages. Customers get an SMS tracking link. Proof of delivery is mentioned, with no detail on how it is captured.
- Toast: it says it integrates seamlessly and with no code or hardware. Toast receives the order, processes it and passes it to VROMO, which picks the delivery provider and sends instructions to the driver.
- Price: $99 a month per location including 400 orders, then $0.25 per order. A two-week free trial after a call with sales.
- Proof it cites: Papa Gino's, using its own delivery agents and DoorDash Drive for peak overflow, and Stoner's Pizza Joint.
Where it falls short for us
- Its stacking is about money, not geography. The stated benefit is one fee for several deliveries, which is a third-party fleet idea. No page gives a batch size, a distance limit or a way to choose which orders belong together.
- Overflow is the headline story. A restaurant whose drivers are the business needs the first run built well, not a way to hand orders off.
- Toast is a one-way description. Orders pass from Toast to VROMO. Nothing says what happens in Toast when a driver is on the road, or whether it can write back.
- Highest published price at high volume. The 400-order allowance is per location per month. A restaurant doing around 1,500 delivery orders a month pays about $374 on the published numbers.
- Its own numbers disagree. The speed claim reads 30% on some pages, 20% on others and 15% on its case-studies page.
- No Clover integration appears anywhere on the site, and driver pay is not mentioned.
Where they are ahead of us
Auto-dispatch rules, timers that can tie into a kitchen display, overflow to outside fleets, tracking links and a track record with pizza chains. Its timers are the nearest thing we found to the "when is an order ready" question.
Pages read: home, features, pricing, Toast, benefits, case studies.
Enterprise delivery software whose big idea is hybrid delivery: your drivers take the orders that matter, outside providers take the rest.
What Cartwheel says
- It calls itself enterprise delivery management software for restaurant chains and catering brands. It names Portillo's, P.F. Chang's, Potbelly, Lou Malnati's, Giordano's and Hungry Howie's, and says it has powered over $1 billion in order value.
- It states plainly that it does not employ drivers or deliver orders. It is the software that runs the operation.
- Dispatch: AI auto-dispatch and auto-batching with AI-optimized routes. It claims 22% faster delivery on its Toast page. Rules can use order value, distance, driver availability, time of day and delivery polygons, and one rule caps the orders per driver.
- Driver app rated 4.6 with about 1,500 ratings, with route planning, one-click navigation, order checklists, chat, and photo, signature, barcode and ID capture.
- Customers get a branded live-tracking link. Tracking can be GPS-based or predicted from POS data.
- Toast: Toast sends the order to Cartwheel Dispatch, which sends priority orders to your drivers and the rest to outside providers. Toast's own help article says the integration needs Toast Partner Integrations, that Cartwheel's team contacts you within 24 hours, and that setup is usually done within two weeks. It repeats that Cartwheel does not provide or source drivers or driver insurance.
- Price: starts at $65 a month per location in the US, with volume and enterprise pricing available. No pricing page was found.
- Pizza proof it cites: Lou Malnati's, Giordano's, Hungry Howie's, and a national pizza chain case study that reports delivery time down from 63 to 47 minutes.
Where it falls short for us
- It is built for chains. The language, the customers, the contact-sales pricing and a two-week onboarding all point to multi-location brands. An independent with one busy kitchen is not who it was written for.
- Hybrid is a hand-off, not a route. Its core idea is deciding which orders go to your drivers and which go outside. That helps when you are short of drivers. The pages say little about how your own drivers' orders are grouped into good runs.
- "Batching" has no detail. The pages say auto-batching exists and give one cap-per-driver rule. They give no distance or timing logic.
- Extra Toast requirement. The restaurant needs Toast Partner Integrations before it can add Cartwheel, and the Toast article does not say what read or write access Cartwheel gets.
- No Clover integration appears on the pages we read, and driver pay is not stated.
Where they are ahead of us
Enterprise logos, a Toast marketplace listing, a highly rated driver app, rule-based dispatch and a published starting price. If a chain already uses Cartwheel, we are not replacing it. We are the answer for the independent that is not a chain.
Pages read: home, hybrid delivery, features, Toast, integrations, and Toast's setup article. The old cartwheel.tech address redirects to trycartwheel.com.
The odd one out. DeliverThat is a catering delivery platform with its own driver network, so it is mostly a partner or overflow option, not a competitor on routing.
What DeliverThat says
- It describes a catering delivery program for restaurant brands, operating since 2013, with 1.4 million deliveries and 11,000+ brands served. Named customers include Taco Cabana, Tocaya and Wegmans.
- Its Toast page says Toast catering orders go straight to its nationwide driver network with no extra screens, and that routing and logistics are handled automatically.
- Orchestration: orders from connected channels are evaluated in real time and sent to the right fulfillment option using rules like order value, source and driver preference, with backup providers if one fails.
- Drivers are vetted, supply their own insulated bags, and it claims average pay over $30 a delivery. Each delivery returns photos and timestamps.
- Its dashboard says it can show orders fulfilled by its fleet, your own drivers or another provider in one place.
- Price: no amounts published. It says there is a flat fee on all deliveries, no volume minimums and no commissions.
Where it falls short for us
- Not a routing tool for your own drivers. The pages do not claim batching, multi-stop runs or route optimization. Its value is that someone else's driver delivers the order.
- Catering, not everyday delivery. It is aimed at catering programs. The only mention of pizza on the pages read is a contrast.
- The opposite economics. A flat fee on every delivery is the cost a restaurant is trying to avoid by running its own drivers.
- The Toast page does not say whether it reads, writes or both.
How we could use it
Shipday, VROMO and Cartwheel all list DeliverThat as an integration. For a restaurant that keeps its own drivers and needs a backup on big catering days, it can sit beside us rather than against us.
Pages read: home, Toast, orchestration, driver fleet, dashboard. No pricing page was found.
Where all of them fall short
This is our analysis, based on what each company publishes. A missing detail on a marketing page does not prove a missing feature, so the next section lists questions that settle each point.
Nobody says how orders become a run
All three dispatch tools claim batching, stacking or route optimization. None of the pages we read gives a batch size, a distance rule, or how long an order waits for neighbours. For a kitchen sending out dozens of orders on a Friday night, that rule is the whole problem, and it is what we let each store set.
They are built around a dispatcher or a driver app
The picture in every case is orders arriving in a dashboard and being assigned to a driver's app. We found nothing about a driver walking up to the counter, choosing a ready-made run and scanning it into the phone's own maps. That counter moment is where a busy delivery restaurant gains or loses minutes.
Toast access is vague
None of the four says whether it reads only or also writes back to Toast. Most describe orders passing from Toast into their system. If drivers are managed in a second tool, someone also has to sign the order out in Toast. Our approach lets the normal Toast sign-out do that job.
The "ready" moment is mostly missing
Only VROMO mentions timers and a kitchen display link. The others do not describe holding an order until the kitchen has made enough of it. That is why we are deciding the right rule carefully.
Prices climb with volume
Shipday and VROMO publish a monthly base plus a per-order charge past an included amount. Cartwheel publishes a starting price per location. As an illustration, take a store doing about 1,500 delivery orders a month on their published numbers: VROMO is about $374 ($99 plus $0.25 on 1,100 orders), Shipday Professional Lite about $101 and Professional about $169, with Shipday's pages inconsistent on whether these are capped. Cartwheel starts at $65 per location and its page lists no per-order rate. Confirm each before quoting.
Several are built for chains or other businesses
Cartwheel is written for enterprise chains. Shipday serves florists and couriers as well as restaurants. DeliverThat is catering. The independent, high-volume, own-driver restaurant is named by most of them and designed around by none.
Questions that test their claims
Ask a restaurant or a POS rep to put these to whoever they are comparing us with, or ask in a demo.
- How many orders can go in one run, and how is distance between stops limited?
- When does an order become eligible for a run, and who decides it is ready?
- What does the driver do at the counter? How many taps, and is anything typed?
- When a driver takes a run, what happens to those orders in Toast? Does anyone sign them out by hand?
- Does it read from Toast, write to Toast, or both, and with whose credentials?
- What is the monthly cost at the restaurant's real delivery volume, with every per-order charge included?
- Is any of this tested at a restaurant that runs its own drivers at high volume, with numbers?
What we should be ready for
They have things we do not yet advertise, and a sharp rep will bring them up: customer tracking links, proof-of-delivery photos, outside-fleet overflow, a Toast marketplace listing and published pricing. Our answer is focus. We solve the part nobody describes in detail: turning a busy kitchen's ready orders into good runs for its own drivers, with no typing.
Compiled on Nov 16, 2026 from each company's own public web pages and Toast's help center. Figures are the companies' marketing claims, are not verified by us, and are paraphrased. Pages and prices change, so recheck before quoting. We have not tested these products. Company names and logos belong to their owners, are linked to their sites, and are used only to identify them. The analysis is BottomLine's own opinion. This page is for internal use and is not linked from the website.
